News and Resources > Is your Credit Documentation and Terms of Trade Unfair?

Is your Credit Documentation and Terms of Trade Unfair?

This article first appeared in Credit Management Magazine, October 2023. Read full Magazine here.

With the introduction of Unfair Contract Terms Regime on November 9th, it is more important than ever for creditors to ensure that their Credit Documentation and Terms of Trade are compliant with existing laws – as failure to do so can now result in your business being exposed to not only increased legal disputes but also new punitive penalties.

In this article, we’ll discuss what these changes mean for you as a creditor and how best approach updating or reviewing the relevant documentation within your business.

Why are these changes significant?

In 2016, when the unfair contract laws were introduced, lawyers took a cautious “wait and see” approach to understand how the courts would define an “unfair term”. However, the landscape has shifted. Effective November 9, 2023, changes to the Unfair Contract Terms Regime now expose your company to significantly higher risks of both increased disputes and penalties.

Under the expanded UCT Laws, unfair contract terms will no longer be deemed unenforceable – they will instead be illegal. This represents a significant shift in the practical application of these laws and requires action by businesses to limit exposure come November 9th.

Which contracts will the new regime effect?

The expanded UCT Laws will apply to standard form small business contracts and consumer contracts entered into or varied on and from 9 November 2023.

Standard form contracts are contracts that have been prepared by one party to the contract (the business offering the product or service) without negotiation between the parties. In other words, it is offered on a ‘take it or leave it’ basis.

A contract is classified as a small business contract when:

    1. it involves the supply of goods or services, or the sale or grant of an interest in land; and
    2. at least one party to the contract is a small business, employing fewer than 100 people and/or having an annual turnover of less than $10 million.

If the ASIC Act applies (if the contract relates to the supply of financial products or services), the contract must also have an upfront price no greater than $5 million.

A contract is deemed a consumer contract when it entails the supply of goods or services, or the sale or grant of an interest in land, to an individual for personal, domestic, or household use and consumption.

How should you prepare for the impending changes?

Your business should be reviewing its standard form contracts and terms and conditions now to ensure they are compliant with the expanded UCT Laws, once they enter into force on 9 November 2023.

What are the key elements for identifying unfair clauses?

When assessing whether any of your contract terms are unfair, it is crucial to consider Section 24 of the Australian Consumer Law. This section outlines three key elements that define an unfair contractual term:

    1. Significantly Imbalanced Rights and Obligations: A term that creates a substantial disparity in the rights and obligations of the parties involved (section 24(1)(a)).
    2. Lack of Reasonable Necessity: The term is not reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the party who would be advantaged by the term (section 24(1)(b)).
    3. Potential for Detriment: the term would cause detriment, whether financial or otherwise, to a party if it were to be applied or relied upon (section 24(1)(c)).

By understanding these criteria, you can effectively determine if any of your contract terms may be deemed unfair.

 

Reference guide to understanding ‘Unfair Terms’

A term is unfair if:

    1. it is not reasonable necessary to protect the legitimate interest of a party; and
    2. it would cause detriment to a party.
    3. it would cause a significant imbalance of rights;

The court may also take into account the transparency of the term and the contract as a whole.  The party alleging a term is unfair bears the onus of establishing it is an unfair term.

In determining whether a contract is standard form, the court may take into account:

    1. the bargaining power of the parties;
    2. who prepared the contract, and when this occurred;
    3. whether the only choice was to accept or reject the terms;
    4. whether there was an opportunity to negotiate; and
    5. whether the contract is tailored to the other party

Understanding what constitutes an unfair term is essential to ensure fair and balanced contracts and limiting exposure.

Each contract must be reviewed on a case-by-case basis and examined in the circumstances to determine whether the contract contains unfair terms.

Your documentation is your best defence

We are witnessing an increase in disputes over unfair terms, even after the service or product has been provided. This is due to businesses taking advantage of the Unfair Contract Terms regime.

With the rise of commercial disputes surrounding unfair contract terms, it’s become more important than ever for businesses to protect themselves with proper documentation.

Final considerations for creditors

As the amendments to Australia’s Unfair Contract Terms Regime come into play, companies and creditors must be aware of the potential risks and penalties that come with them.

The changes could expose businesses to legal disputes and punitive fines, which can have a significant impact on bottom lines. To mitigate these risks, it’s important to ensure that companies’ contracts comply with the new regulations.

Creditors must also be vigilant in identifying any unfair contract terms that could hurt their business, such as clauses that offer little to no benefit to customers or that limit the company’s liability. By taking these precautions, creditors can help their companies weather the changes to the Unfair Contract Terms Regime and stay on top of legal risks.

Are you unsure if your credit documentation is compliant with expanded UCT Laws?

If you need assistance, wish to discuss the expanded UCT Laws, or would like for us to complete a no cost review of your terms of trade or credit documentation, please contact the Results Legal team on 1300 757 534 or via email at info@resultslegal.com.au.

Anna Taylor MICM
Principal
View details
Contact us – We are here to help
If you need legal advice or representation of specialist commercial lawyers concerning a case involving your business, please contact our team at Results Legal on 1300 757 534 or use our contact form to send us a message.

email us for a consultation

Call us 1300 757 534

Trade Credit and Debt Recovery Trends

Trade Credit and Debt Recovery Trends

In this video, Results Legal Manging Director Karl Hill discusses what we’re seeing in the trade credit and debt recovery sector in more detail.

Our goal is to assist credit managers and professionals in the credit industry by providing valuable insights into the changing economic and financial landscape.

By staying informed about evolving patterns, you can effectively manage credit risks and identify opportunities to position your business for success. Understanding developments in trade credit and debt recovery will enable you to create strategies for risk mitigation and capitalise on growth prospects in a fluctuating market. This knowledge is vital for

Unfair Contracts: Frequently Asked Questions

Unfair Contracts: Frequently Asked Questions

As the changes to the Unfair Contract Terms Regime have now come into effect, many of our clients have been seeking clarification on what this means for their businesses.

With the new legislation in place, it’s important for companies to fully understand their obligations and ensure they are compliant.

Over the last few months, we have received a range of questions regarding the Unfair Contract Terms Regime, from what constitutes an unfair term to how to draft contracts that align with the new regulations.

In the video below, Special Counsel Robert Shepley has provided answers to some of the most

Results Legal Welcomes Rob Shepley to Lead New Commercial Division

Results Legal Welcomes Rob Shepley to Lead New Commercial Division

Our primary goal is to achieve better commercial outcomes for our clients.

With that in mind, we’re proud to announce the appointment of Special Counsel Robert Shepley who has joined Results to head up our new commercial division.

Results Legal has been a specialist in commercial dispute resolution, focusing on areas such as debt recovery, insolvency, and commercial litigation since its inception.

Our goal is to proactively assist clients in achieving the best possible commercial results. Managing Director Karl Hill said of the appointment, “We believe that early involvement in a transaction is crucial for avoiding disputes and ensuring cost-effective

Corporate Counsel’s Guide to The Unfair Contracts Regime Changes

Corporate Counsel’s Guide to The Unfair Contracts Regime Changes

From 9 November 2023, the amended Unfair Contract Terms Regime is in effect.

 It is crucial for Australian businesses and their legal teams to be fully aware of the potential risks involved.

The consequences of non-compliance include hefty penalties and increased exposure to legal disputes.

Special Counsel Robert Shepley has created the Corporate Counsel’s Guide to the Unfair Contract Terms Regime to help legal teams ensure that their businesses are protected from the risks of unfair terms, ultimately safeguarding their commercial interests.

Download the Corporate Counsel’s Guide to the Unfair Contract Terms Regime

Enter your details below and

Results Legal Trends Report November 2023

Results Legal Trends Report November 2023

The current market is challenging and the effects on businesses from COVID are still playing out.

In a recent video, Managing Director Karl Hill provides valuable insights into the market conditions that our clients are experiencing, sharing not only an overview of trends we are seeing in our areas of specialisation, industry trends and recent regulatory changes, but also touching on some of the key matters we are working on.

Topics covered in this video include:

  • Banking & Finance
  • Shareholder & Partnership Disputes
  • Insolvency & Restructuring
  • Trade Credit & Debt Recovery
  • Changes to the Unfair Contract Terms Regime

[Webinar] The New Unfair Contracts Terms: What it means for your business

[Webinar] The New Unfair Contracts Terms: What it means for your business

Onerous and punishing – the new unfair contract terms regime will affect thousands of businesses standard form of contracts.

Is your business prepared for the changes? 

Join us at 12pm on Wednesday, May 24th as we hear Anna Taylor – Principal at Results Legal and Jeff George – Head of Risk and Group Services of NCI discuss the upcoming changes to the unfair contract terms regime which come into force on 9 November 2023.

About the Webinar

The changes to the unfair contract terms regime bring about significant changes which will likely affect all

Set-Off And Peak-Indebtedness Get The Axe In MJ Woodman And Badenoch Logging Judgments

Set-Off And Peak-Indebtedness Get The Axe In MJ Woodman And Badenoch Logging Judgments

The High Court delivered two judgments on 8 February 2023 to bring about the most significant development to the unfair preference laws and ended many years of uncertainty in relation to the defence of set-off and the application of the running account principle.

For many years, there has been heated debate as to whether:

    1. set-off is available as a defence to an unfair preference claim; and
    2. the “peak-indebtedness rule” is part of the law in Australia.

The High Court decisions of Metal Manufactures Pty Limited v Morton [2023] HCA 1 (Morton) and Bryant v Badenoch Integrated Logging

Litigation Funding – a Tool for Creditors?

Litigation Funding - a Tool for Creditors?

Litigation funding is a little used tool that can yield big benefits for unsecured creditors.

If employed strategically by creditors, litigation funding can enable the creditor to seek a priority payment, which may result in a significant recovery.